Théorie & Réglage·1 min read·Débutant

Mechanical or automatic movement: the differences

Mechanical and automatic watches: Seiko and IWC winding examples, ETA power reserve, COSC certification and the Quartz Astron milestone.

Comparing documented constructions

Mechanical, automatic and quartz movements

In the mechanical context discussed here, an automatic is a mechanical watch with automatic winding. IWC’s Pellaton system illustrates how rotor movement is transferred to the mainspring; it does not describe every architecture. IWC — the Pellaton system.

Hand-winding capability depends on the calibre: Seiko’s 7S26/7S35/7S36/4R15/4R16 do not provide it, while the 4R35/4R36 do. Follow the manual for starting and winding, without universal intervals or resistance thresholds. Seiko — 7S and 4R calibre instructions.

ETA specifies a typical power reserve of 42 hours and a minimum of 38 hours for the 2824-2. This is not a shared running time for all automatic watches. ETA — 2824-2 technical communication.

In the context of mechanical certification, COSC gives an average daily rate criterion of −4 to +6 seconds per day. This is a test criterion, not a universal on-wrist guarantee or a rule for every certified instrument. COSC — chronometer certification.

Seiko states that the Quartz Astron went on sale on 25 December 1969 and describes it as the world’s first quartz wristwatch. This milestone does not support general promises of accuracy, longevity or repairability for an entire category. Seiko — the Quartz Astron story.

Décalibre School

Frequently asked questions

Can an automatic watch be wound too much?

Follow the calibre instructions; no universal guarantee against overwinding is established here.

Does an automatic watch need a watch winder?

Reviewed sources do not establish that one is necessary; follow the manufacturer’s recommendations.

Which watch should a beginner choose?

The choice depends on your preferences; this article compares mechanical, automatic and quartz principles.

Official sources